You Can See Everything is not a conventional retelling of the Theranos scandal. It does not open with a timeline of Elizabeth Holmes's rise, nor does it spend most of its running time reconstructing the courtroom evidence that led to her conviction. Instead, the documentary turns its attention to the final month before Holmes reported to prison and to the strange, intimate relationship she developed with Nathan Fielder, the comedian and filmmaker whose deadpan style has long been built around testing social boundaries. The result is a film that is less about whether Holmes lied than about how persuasion operates when the person doing the persuading seems completely sincere.
The central question is blunt: Can you trust her? For anyone who followed the fraud trial, that question may appear to have been settled. Holmes was found guilty of one count of conspiracy and three counts of wire fraud. The evidence was extensive. It included forged memos that appeared to come from pharmaceutical companies that had done testing with Theranos, recordings in which Holmes overstated the company's capabilities, and testimony from employees who said they warned her that the proprietary blood-testing technology was not accurate and were dismissed. The company had once been valued at $9 billion, attracted investors such as media mogul Rupert Murdoch, and placed figures such as Henry Kissinger on its board. It had a retail partnership with a national pharmacy chain and generated enormous press attention. But its central promise—that it could run a wide range of tests on a single drop of blood using its own devices—did not hold up. Most tests were run on modified commercially available machines, and only a small number were performed on Theranos's own platform.
Key facts at a glance
- You Can See Everything is a documentary about Elizabeth Holmes, Nathan Fielder, and the question of whether Holmes can be trusted.
- Fielder filmed Holmes during her last month of freedom before prison and stayed in contact with her for roughly two years while she served her sentence.
- Holmes was convicted of one count of conspiracy and three counts of wire fraud in connection with Theranos.
- The film focuses on Holmes's one-on-one charisma, her use of eye contact and active listening, and the way she makes people feel uniquely positioned to understand her.
- Holmes insists she did not lie and that she believed in her invention; she also offers a future-tense interpretation of her claims that the company's machines 'can' perform certain tests.
- Billy Evans, Holmes's partner, becomes a central figure, especially around questions of control, money, and image management.
- Amanda Seyfried appears as herself and reenacts off-camera interactions between Holmes and Fielder, effectively reprising her role as Holmes from a previous dramatization.
The documentary's most unsettling material comes from watching Holmes explain herself. Early in the film, Fielder asks whether she chose him because he is not a science specialist and might be easier to fool. Holmes rejects the premise. She says she sees her story as a human story. She says she has been misunderstood. She is not the fraudster people made her out to be, she insists; she did not lie to anyone; she believed in what she was building. As she speaks, she holds eye contact. Her face is calm, almost peaceful. She appears to be fully convinced. At one point she says she has never told a lie at all, not once in her life. The claim is extraordinary on its face, but the film's power lies in how briefly it can seem plausible—especially if a viewer is not holding a stack of trial exhibits in mind.
The future-tense defense
The film returns repeatedly to one linguistic defense. Holmes had claimed that Theranos's machines could perform more than 1,000 tests. In reality, only a couple hundred were listed as options on the company's website, and far fewer were actually run on the proprietary device. When Fielder presses her on this, Holmes says that when she used the word 'can,' she meant the machine could perform those tests if the necessary chemistry were developed. It was a future-tense 'can,' a statement about potential rather than present capability. On one level, the explanation is a familiar piece of corporate hedging. On another, it is a demonstration of how Holmes can retreat into a literal reading of her own words while avoiding the question of what listeners were meant to understand.
Fielder tries to take the future-tense 'can' seriously by showing Holmes the classic Abbott and Costello comedy routine 'Who's on First.' The sketch is built on confusion between names and questions, and it has been famous for decades. Holmes says she has not heard of it. She laughs along, but when asked what is funny, she appears to draw a blank. She cannot produce the name of the first baseman. Fielder's experiment is not a formal interrogation, but it works as a kind of stress test. If Holmes cannot or will not follow a simple comedy routine about the slipperiness of language, how is anyone supposed to pin down what she meant when she talked about what her machines 'can' do? The film does not resolve whether Holmes genuinely fails to understand the routine or deliberately refuses to understand it. What matters is that understanding it would require her to admit that the future-tense 'can' misled people.
Holmes's partner, Billy Evans, offers his own explanation: Holmes's mind does not work like other people's. The film treats this less as a defense than as another piece of the puzzle. Fielder is a master manipulator in his own right—his work often depends on creating awkward situations and seeing how people respond—but he is also not a forensic accountant. He is not poring over the written record. The only extended clip of Theranos-era Holmes in the film is a brief recorded conversation that sets up the discussion of 'can.' In the absence of documents, talking to someone who appears perfectly confident and candid while making questionable claims is disorienting. Onscreen, Fielder wants to believe her. He may not believe her, not really, but he wants to.
The intimacy of persuasion
The film's visual language emphasizes proximity. In early scenes, Fielder lurks awkwardly in the background or around a corner. Gradually, Holmes draws him in. She asks what he thinks. She engages him in conversation. Her eye contact does much of the work. At one point, Fielder asks how she and Evans met and whether she was flirting with him. She was. He asks how she flirts. She says, while holding eye contact with Fielder, by holding eye contact at length. The direction, by Lance Oppenheim and Fielder, repeatedly places the two men and Holmes in very close physical proximity. In some scenes they appear to be about to kiss. The effect is not romantic so much as tactical: it shows how Holmes creates a sense of shared confidence.
This is notable because of who Holmes operates best on: men. At Theranos she was often the only woman in a room full of male investors, board members, and executives. But the seduction in the documentary is not the femme fatale style of noir films. It is eye contact, active listening, and physical proximity. Holmes gives Fielder—and presumably the other men in her life—the feeling of being fully heard and understood. On top of that, there is a second layer: the promise that the person she is talking to is uniquely qualified to understand her because he is special. Holmes's charisma is not simply about her. It is about how she makes her interlocutor feel.
Evans tries to reproduce that same dynamic with Fielder. He suggests that Holmes has been misunderstood and persecuted, but that Fielder is special enough to see her side. Fielder sees through it immediately. When Evans says, 'I know what you're feeling,' Fielder dismisses the claim: 'No, you don't.' The contrast is revealing. Holmes can make the same kind of appeal and get further, at least for a while. Evans's attempt is too blunt, too obviously instrumental. Holmes's version is smoother because it is built into the rhythm of conversation.
Billy Evans and the problem of protection
Evans becomes the focus of much of the film's second half. His relationship with Holmes raises questions about control, dependency, and image management. Early in the documentary, he takes a bowl of eggs from Holmes and beats them more forcefully than she does before handing it back. Holmes tells Fielder that Evans does not like how she beats eggs, implying that this is a recurring correction. The moment is small, but it establishes a pattern. Before Holmes goes to prison, Evans has her photographed to create an avatar of herself—a kind of hologram that can generate messages from letters she might write. When Fielder raises the concern that such technology could be used to create nude or compromising deepfakes of Holmes, Evans essentially shrugs. Evans also takes over Holmes's social media account and posts in a style that does not sound like her. He says he did not get the password from Holmes; he got it from employees at the platform.
Holmes tells Fielder that she does not like having her picture taken and that she did not like the press attention around Theranos. Fielder treats this as a concern about Evans—a sign that Evans may be manipulating Holmes. But the statement sits in complete conflict with Holmes inviting a film crew into her home to make a documentary about herself. Holmes has a long record of seeking attention. During the Theranos years, she wrote about using the media to drown out and refute criticism. She liked the attention and believed she could control it. The documentary's portrait of Evans as a would-be protector is therefore complicated by the possibility that Holmes is not simply being controlled. She may also be outsourcing conflict to someone willing to handle it for her.
That arrangement has costs. In order to operate as she did at Theranos—delegating confrontation to a man nearby—Holmes has to accept that many well-balanced people do not want to be human shields. The men most willing to fight for her are often the men who want to fight. The men most eager to protect her are also the ones most likely to want to control her. The film suggests this was part of the problem with Sunny Balwani, Holmes's former partner and codefendant, and it suggests the same dynamic may be present with Evans. It is also present, in a different way, with Fielder. His team has final cut. The people who agree to be used are also the people most likely to turn around and use Holmes.
Reenactment and the limits of the record
One of the documentary's strangest and most effective choices is the use of Amanda Seyfried. Seyfried appears as herself, functioning as a kind of audience stand-in for Fielder, and she also reenacts interactions that took place off camera. She had previously played Holmes in a dramatized miniseries, so her presence adds another layer of performance. In the film, Seyfried and Fielder discuss an off-camera episode in which Evans, with Holmes out of the room, demanded payment for the documentary, and producers conceded. Seyfried acts out the scene. The film cuts between the discussion and the reenactment, asking whether Holmes knew what Evans was doing and deliberately stepped away so that he could ask, or whether she was being taken advantage of by yet another would-be Svengali.
Fielder later visits Holmes in prison. He describes the conversation to Seyfried in ambiguous terms. Seyfried immediately asks whether he is protecting Holmes, whether he is leaving something out. Fielder's reply is vague. The film does not provide a clean answer. It shows Evans at times appearing unstable, especially near the end. When he meets Seyfried, he tells her she is not good at social media because of comments she made about a public figure's death. He goes on an aggressive, paranoid rant, saying he is always armed and that no one would like his politics. The constant sniffing, aggression, and paranoia are presented without diagnosis, but they are unsettling. It is this version of Evans who claims Holmes does not know he asked for a cut of the documentary proceeds. It is also this version who says he consults a mental version of Holmes to know what she would want, so that the real Holmes does not enter the loop.
After the film, text reveals that Evans gave up his financial stake in the documentary. The project was meant as image rehabilitation, and the conflict of interest—along with its appearance in the film itself—undercuts that goal. The documentary gives viewers the disorienting, claustrophobic experience of dealing with Holmes in real time. Holmes is a specific case, but the problem Fielder faces is broader. Most of the time, people cannot pause a relationship and consult written evidence. Federal prosecutors may have read Holmes's emails and messages in open court, but ordinary life does not work that way. People have to decide whether they are willing to trust someone.
Exactly how far Fielder was taken in remains unresolved. The film shows Holmes's 'you got this' goodbye as she leaves for prison. It includes a reenacted scene of Holmes comforting Fielder about a breakup over the phone from prison and a reenacted prison hug. Early in the documentary, Holmes invites Fielder to swim in the ocean, and he says he does not like cold water and is not sure what breaking that boundary would mean. At the end, after Seyfried asks whether Fielder is protecting Holmes, the film shows footage of the two of them playing in the ocean. It looks like Fielder got got. It is also a deliberate choice to place those scenes in that order, which is part of what makes the film feel like high art. Either Fielder is manipulating Holmes and the audience to seem more malleable than he is, or the filmmakers are showing that Fielder was successfully manipulated. There is no written record to settle it. Viewers are left with the same task the film assigns to Fielder: decide what to believe about a person who is very good at making belief feel like a personal invitation.
Source: The Verge News